Voices on HPV vaccination, Texas mandate

Of the many opinions expressed in the media over the past 10 days regarding the executive order by Texas Gov. Rick Perry, here are a few worth noting:

• Friday's USA Today included a point-counterpoint on the Texas mandate order. The USA Today editorial board questions the timing of the mandate. The headline and subhead of the story sums up their argument nicely: "Rush to require cancer shot threatens to promote backlash; HPV vaccine holds great promise, but Texas mandate is premature."

• On the same page, Gov. Perry (or more likely, a member of his staff) responded in a short commentary titled "My order protects life." It frames the decision less as a matter of instituting a 'mandate', but rather, implementing an 'opt-out' system of vaccination instead of an 'opt-in' system. Given the relative ease of obtaining exemptions (to the chagrin of vaccine advocates), that terminology is probably more precise than speaking about 'mandates', with its connotation of compulsion.

• Arthur Allen, author of Vaccine (which we noted previously and was reviewed this weekend in the Washington Post) wrote an op-ed that appeared in several papers last week. Titled "Idea behind the decision is sound, but Perry's timing is off," the piece makes an argument similar to that of the USA Today editorial. He writes, "By imposing the HPV vaccine in such a rushed, questionable way, Mr. Perry's action threatens to mobilize people who, under normal circumstances, would simply do what they were told, assuming it was best for them."

• In this AP story in the Seattle Post-Intelligencer, Washington Gov. Chris Gregoire voiced skepticism at Perry's decision. "'I told the medical association that I was reticent to dictate when I think there is a lot of public education that needs to go on,' Gregoire said. 'To go out and start just saying everybody mandatorily has to have this is a little bit troublesome for me.'"

• Finally, Art Caplan and James Colgrove appeared on "Radio Times," a Philadelphia-based NPR program, to discuss HPV vaccination, the Texas mandate, and related topics regarding the ethics of vaccines. You can listen to the one-hour program here.